Sir Arthur Sullivan, The Mikado, and the Mendelssohn Glee Club

If you’ve ever found yourself humming a melody that feels at once deeply Victorian, deliciously witty, and effortlessly catchy, chances are high that Sir Arthur Sullivan had a hand in it.

As our choir prepares to perform the famous Madrigal ("Brightly Dawns Our Wedding Day") from Gilbert & Sullivan’s classic comic opera The Mikado, we wanted to take a moment to look back at the origins of this masterpiece—and the surprising historical threads connecting it directly to our own performance traditions!

Who Was Arthur Sullivan?

Sir Arthur Sullivan (1842–1900) was one of the most celebrated British musicians of the 19th century. Classically trained at the Royal Academy of Music in London and the Leipzig Conservatoire, Sullivan was viewed by his contemporaries—and himself—as the grand hope of English serious music.

However, his astronomical success alongside librettist W. S. Gilbert in comic operetta often eclipsed his serious classical ambitions. Together, "G&S" defined Victorian light opera with worldwide hits like H.M.S. Pinafore, The Pirates of Penzance, and The Mikado.

The Tension Between "Serious" Ambitions and Operetta

Throughout his life, Sullivan felt a deep conflict between the commercial demands of operetta and his desire to compose "higher" musical art:

• Symphonic & Concert Works: Early in his career, Sullivan composed notable classical orchestral works, including his acclaimed Symphony in E ("Irish") (1866), a Cello Concerto in E minor (1866), and dramatic overtures such as Overture Di Ballo (1870) and In Memoriam (1866).

• Grand Opera: Sullivan longed to establish a national British grand opera tradition. His primary contribution to the genre was his full-scale grand opera Ivanhoe (1891), based on Sir Walter Scott’s novel. It ran for an unprecedented 160 consecutive performances at the Royal English Opera House, though it remains his only grand opera.

• Sacred Choral Masterpieces & Hymns: Sullivan also dedicated considerable energy to sacred music, composing grand choral cantatas like The Golden Legend (1886) and beloved hymns—most famously composing the tune for "Onward, Christian Soldiers" (1871).

The Partnership: Gilbert & Sullivan

How They Met

W. S. Gilbert (the satirist and librettist) and Arthur Sullivan were first introduced in late 1869 by composer Frederic Clay during a rehearsal at the Royal Gallery of Illustration. At their very first meeting, Gilbert immediately tested Sullivan’s musical cleverness by posing a bizarre hypothetical question about musical meter—setting the tone for a creative partnership defined by sharp wit and intellectual sparring.

Which Came First: Words or Music?

In the G&S creative pipeline, the words almost always came first.

Gilbert would write a complete libretto and lyric set, carefully establishing exact rhythms and verse structures. He would then hand the text to Sullivan without revealing what tune or cadence he had in mind. Sullivan would analyze the rhythmic meter of Gilbert's words, discover their inherent musicality, and compose original melodies that perfectly matched the natural speech stress of the English language.

Creative Friction and the "Lozenge Plot"

Despite their extraordinary synergy on stage, Gilbert and Sullivan were very different personalities. Gilbert was prickly, litigious, and exacting; Sullivan was polished, aristocratic, and eager for social and artistic respectability.

Their working relationship was frequently strained by artistic disagreements, often linked directly to Sullivan’s desire to stop writing "frivolous" comic pieces:

• The "Lozenge" Plot Rejections: After the success of Princess Ida (1884), Sullivan declared he would write no more light operettas, complaining that Gilbert’s plots were too formulaic and relied on absurd magic devices (such as a magic lozenge that changed people's identities). Sullivan demanded plots with real human emotion and natural drama. Gilbert was offended, but after months of deadlock, he abandoned the magic lozenge idea and presented a completely grounded satire on British institutions—which became The Mikado.

• The Infamous Carpet Quarrel: In 1890, their partnership broke down entirely over a financial dispute regarding a £140 carpet purchased for the front-of-house at the Savoy Theatre by producer Richard D'Oyly Carte. When Sullivan sided with Carte over the theatre expenses rather than backing Gilbert, an indignant Gilbert sued, causing a rift that halted their collaboration for years.

The Mikado & Its Journey Across the Pond

The premiere of The Mikado at London’s Savoy Theatre in March 1885 took the world by storm. Set in a fictionalized version of Japan to satirize British politics and social snobbery, the opera was an instant phenomenon.

Demand was so intense that Mikado-mania crossed the Atlantic almost immediately:

• Summer 1885: Unauthorized "pirate" productions sprang up across America, starting with hastily assembled stagings in Chicago in July 1885.

• August 1885: Producer Richard D'Oyly Carte secretly brought his official London company over to New York's Fifth Avenue Theatre to launch the official, authorized U.S. premiere on August 19, 1885.

American audiences were instantly hooked, and The Mikado became a permanent fixture of American theatrical and choral repertoire.

What's Happening in the Madrigal? Is it Really a Bright Day?

On its surface, "Brightly Dawns Our Wedding Day" sounds like a serene, idyllic Renaissance madrigal—a gentle, glowing celebration of love and marriage. But in true Gilbert & Sullivan fashion, underneath the lush, shimmering harmonies lies a classic example of G&S dramatic irony.

The Plot Context

In Act II of The Mikado, the young lovers Yum-Yum and Nanki-Poo are preparing to wed. Joined by Pitti-Sing and the Lord High Executioner, Ko-Ko, the quartet sings this elegant madrigal praising the joy and radiance of their wedding morning:

"Brightly dawns our wedding day,Joyous hour, we give thee greeting!Whither, whither art thou fleeting?"

The Grim Catch

The catch? The marriage is a sham designed to avoid an execution, and Nanki-Poo has agreed to be executed in one month's time!

According to a bizarre decree by the Mikado (the Emperor), the town of Titipu must produce an execution or face severe penalties. Ko-Ko strikes a bargain with Nanki-Poo: Nanki-Poo can marry Yum-Yum today, on the strict condition that at the end of thirty days, he voluntarily submits to being beheaded by Ko-Ko!

To make matters worse, as the four finish singing their sweet, buoyant verses celebrating the bright morning, a sobering truth dawns on them: under Titipu law, when a married man is executed, his widow must be buried alive with him!

The madrigal shifts abruptly from pure romantic bliss to a poignant, bittersweet contemplation of mortality. Sullivan underlines this dramatic turn masterfully—the music moves into a minor-key melancholy as the singers repeat the haunting refrain:

"Sing a merry mad expression...Let us dry the starting tear!Dull despair and slow depressing,Sorrow passes, joy is near!"

It is precisely this brilliant juxtaposition—a gorgeous, sublime vocal melody delivering a darkly comedic realization—that makes the Madrigal one of Sullivan’s undisputed masterworks.

Gilbert & Sullivan: A Staple of the Mendelssohn Glee Club

Since its founding in 1866, the Mendelssohn Glee Club of New York has maintained a long and affectionate relationship with the music of Arthur Sullivan and the Savoy operas. As part of the club’s historical mission to promote secular part-songs and gentlemen’s choral singing, Sullivan's vocal music became a natural cornerstone of MGC concert programming across three centuries.

Key Works in the Club's Repertoire:

• The Long Day Closes (1868): Perhaps Sullivan's most famous standalone TTBB secular part-song, this serene masterpiece has been a perennial staple of the Mendelssohn Glee Club's classical repertoire, showcasing the ensemble's delicate dynamic control and rich vocal blending.

• Madrigal ("Brightly Dawns Our Wedding Day") from The Mikado: Originally written as a bittersweet mixed-voice (SATB) quartet in Act II of The Mikado, this piece has long been cherished by the club in a specialized four-part male voice (TTBB) setting.

• Operatic Choruses & Ensemble Numbers: Over the decades, the Mendelssohn Glee Club has frequently featured TTBB choral selections, choruses, and ensemble numbers from across the G&S canon—including highlights from H.M.S. Pinafore, The Pirates of Penzance, Iolanthe, and The Gondoliers—bringing Victorian theatrical flair to New York concert halls.

Cesare Sodero: Conductor, Arranger, and Pillar of MGC

While The Mikado's Madrigal was originally written for a mixed quartet, the version we perform today is a special male-chorus arrangement crafted by a figure central to our club's own history: Cesare Sodero (1886–1947).

A Master on the Podium

Cesare Sodero was an Italian-born prodigy cellist, composer, and conductor who made a profound mark on American musical life. Before going on to serve as a conductor at the Metropolitan Opera in the 1940s—where he conducted over 150 performances of Verdi, Puccini, and the core Italian repertoire—Sodero held the baton as conductor of the Mendelssohn Glee Club.

During his tenure leading the Mendelssohn Glee Club, Sodero brought operatic precision, vocal texture, and instrumental balance to our rehearsals and performances. Drawing on his background as a cellist, he treated the four male vocal parts (TTBB) with the same lyrical phrasing and rich warmth as string sections.

Bringing G&S to the Male Chorus

Sodero’s extensive experience conducting light opera and grand opera gave him a natural affinity for Gilbert & Sullivan’s sparkling ensemble numbers. As a master orchestrator, he knew how to translate Sullivan's original SATB vocal counterpoint into rich TTBB sonorities specifically tailored for the voice types of the Mendelssohn Glee Club.

Through Sodero’s custom arrangement, our performance of The Mikado's madrigal carries forward a double legacy: celebrating Arthur Sullivan’s musical genius while honoring the musical hand of one of our club’s former conductors!

Conclusion: Sullivan’s Enduring Genius and Our Shared Heritage

Ultimately, while Arthur Sullivan may have harbored a lifelong desire to be remembered primarily for his symphonies and grand operas, history reveals that his true immortality lies in his matchless gift for vocal melody and ensemble writing. In the Madrigal from The Mikado, Sullivan achieved what few composers ever could: crafting a piece of pure classical beauty that effortlessly balances subtle dramatic irony, flawless contrapuntal texture, and irresistible warmth. When the Mendelssohn Glee Club takes the stage to sing Cesare Sodero’s lush TTBB setting, we do not merely perform a piece of theatrical history—we honor the intersecting legacies of a master British composer, an iconic Italian-American conductor who shaped our club’s artistic voice, and a 160-year-old choral tradition that continues to bring these timeless harmonies to life.

Would you like help preparing this draft to be sent out via Mailchimp or published directly on the MGC website?